Opinion|Videos|July 17, 2025

Optimizing Immunotherapy in SCAC: Clinical Decision-Making for IO Selection and Cytotoxic Integration

Panelists discuss how treatment selection between combination immunotherapy (IO) and chemotherapy alone should favor the FDA-approved carboplatin-paclitaxel-retifanlimab regimen for most patients with metastatic anal cancer, while avoiding checkpoint inhibitors in solid organ transplant recipients and maintaining that different checkpoint inhibitors are not necessarily interchangeable without specific trial data.

Immunotherapy Integration and Future Considerations

The question of checkpoint inhibitor interchangeability remains complex, with literature examples showing that swapping one immunotherapy agent for another does not necessarily maintain efficacy. The distinction between different checkpoint inhibitors may be significant, as demonstrated in studies like KeyNote-590 vs CheckMate-649 in esophageal cancer. Until additional data emerge, clinicians should adhere to studied regimens rather than substituting agents based on availability or convenience.

Practical implementation challenges include insurance authorization delays, with payers often requiring peer-to-peer reviews for combination therapies. The scientific rationale supports maintaining cytotoxic chemotherapy alongside immunotherapy due to synergistic efficacy, which is particularly important for symptomatic patients requiring rapid response. The combination approach provides both immediate cytotoxic effect and potentially durable immunotherapy response, addressing both symptom control and long-term disease management.

Access barriers for patients living far from treatment centers present logistical challenges, particularly with weekly paclitaxel administration combined with every-4-week immunotherapy. However, experts recommend maintaining published dosing schedules rather than modifying to every-3-week regimens without safety data, emphasizing patient travel arrangements over protocol modifications. The discussion acknowledges this represents a real-world challenge requiring individualized solutions while maintaining treatment efficacy.


Latest CME